Introduction to integrated methods in the vegetable garden
Chapter : Biocontrols
Previous or next articles ; click on a title to go to the page
⇒ Anti-insect nets
Radishes, carrots, turnips, celeriac, onions, leeks, etc. can be effectively protected against root pests by using nets made of small meshes that allow sunlight, air and water to pass through. I have found that polyester and polyethylene netting (e.g. Diatex) is more UV-resistant than the polyamide netting sold in some garden shops. These nets prevent many adult insects from laying eggs on the collars of plants or on the ground near the plants. Depending on the size of the mesh used, they provide a mechanical barrier against butterflies, flies, thrips .....
Most of the nets proposed for market gardening in the field allow good aeration with a very limited greenhouse effect. As the mesh size of the nets is tightened to fit the size of the insects, the temperature and humidity inside these shelters increase.
All the trials I have undertaken have shown that for root vegetables, a 1 mm mesh size that prevents the passage of adult flies and moths is a good compromise for root protection with an acceptable increase in internal temperature (about 1 degree). These nets also protect the stems and leaves against locusts, snails, caterpillars and maggots of pests. Below one millimetre, there is a risk of problematic increases in internal temperature for some plants, at least in the Provence-Alpes-Côte d’Azur region (not verified for other regions).
Although an Insect netting allows air to circulate, the level of humidity from evaporation of water from the soil is higher inside the Insect netting, even in the middle of summer in the Provence-Alpes-Côte d’Azur region. This level of humidity depends on the size of the mesh and the amount of water supplied by the irrigation. Excessive humidity sometimes manifests itself on the soil by the appearance of green unicellular algae. This should be taken into account for certain vegetables, such as lettuce, which do not tolerate a humid atmosphere. To reduce the humidity inside the covers, it is preferable to use drip irrigation rather than overhead irrigation. Insect netting can be folded back when there is a significant reduction in early summer pests such as aphids.
Insect netting is certainly the most effective method of protection against root pests without the need for plant protection treatments that have been used for many years. For long-term crops with winter storage (such as carrots with frost protection). Some damage can be seen, probably caused by the accidental introduction of pests, for example when nets are folded up for a few hours for weeding.
Some pests require tighter mesh netting. The tobacco whitefly (Bemisia tabaci) is a polyphagous crop pest that has recently become established in the Mediterranean. In case of nuisance, mechanical protection against this bio-pest requires the installation of meshes with holes smaller than the size of the animal's thorax, i.e. approximately 0.20 mm.
Without crop rotation, there is little point in using these nets, especially if you are installing protection for the first time over soil that has already received infected root vegetables. Inside the covers, when the pest pulps buried in the soil produce adults, they will be protected from their own predators. Any weeds that are thought to harbour pests should be removed from the plot where the protection tunnels will be installed. The cleanliness of the soil is essential to reduce the risk of polyphagous pests appearing inside the protections. This is for example the case of radishes which will still take the maggot if field mustard is present on the ground before the installation of the nets.
For the same reasons, the addition of organic matter is only possible if it does not contain the pulp of a bio-pest; for this, it is necessary to spread refined compost that has undergone a thermophilic phase (see the article on the production of hot compost). Other more or less useful insects whose larvae overwinter in the soil may also appear inside the nets.
Insect nets are all the more useful as some insects have become resistant to certain pesticides. For example, onion and carrot flies are often resistant to chlorinated insecticides. Most registered insecticides that can destroy root vegetable pest eggs and larvae are reserved for professional farmers because of their toxicity. Anti-insect nets thus make it possible to avoid using these phytosanitary products.
These nets allow air and light to pass through and allow watering by sprinkling. Do not buy nets from an internet site if the mesh size is not known. These nets should be wide enough to be held in place by 2-metre hoops so as not to compress the leaves too much. Drip irrigation can also be introduced inside the nets.
Noctuid moth on insect netting to protect carrots
The price and quality of these nets vary greatly from one supplier to another. Some nets have thicker wires than others, which does not guarantee that they are stronger. An anti-insect net must be strong and light (resistant to the clips on the hoops), transparent (the plants inside the protection must be visible) and allow water to pass through easily and avoid excessive temperature rise inside the protection. The mesh size should be regular. Some nets can be reused for several years after deleting any small holes. These openings appear from time to time and can be filled with a drop of PVC glue known to be waterproof, which is available in all DIY shops. This glue does not adhere to the fibres; it seals the small holes by trapping the fibres to form a sufficiently strong and watertight structure. The origin of these small openings is often accidental due to handling by the grower, or caused by animals such as cats, or possibly insects and other animals that try to get inside the protection.
Here is an internet address that I highly recommend where you can get very good quality insect netting as well as bows and fixing clips; click here
It is preferable to use Biotex insect-proof netting - 40gr/m² which has a minimum life span of 3 years.
Note that some growers use anti-insect nets without hoops and placed directly on the crops; more information by clicking here
Insect netting tears easily at the low attachment points on the ground when, for example, wooden boards are used to prevent bio-agressors from entering the shelter. Weeds tend to grow in these areas and their roots get caught in the mesh and are difficult to remove. Therefore, any seedlings that become attached to the mesh should be removed as soon as possible.
At the end of the growing season, the edges of the insect netting can be easily cleaned with a hose.
The lifespan of an insect net is one to three years depending on the model. However, I have found that with proper maintenance, they can be used for longer.
Below is a list of some vegetables that can easily be protected with insect netting. A brief description of the most common root pests is also given.
Insect netting is effective in controlling flea beetles, which produce small holes in the leaves. They also prevent the settlement of the Delia radicum maggot, which is also present on crucifers and radishes. The first damage appears mainly in May. Flea beetles are small beetles that find shelter in grass and wild crucifers. For this reason, all weeds must be removed from the area where the insect netting is to be installed, otherwise the protection will become a flea beetle farm, protected from their predators. Insect netting is necessary throughout the crop to provide particularly effective protection against these devastating pests without using a single drop of organic or synthetic pesticide.
It should be noted that flea beetles may appear in shelters if turnips in pots have been grown in the open air. Flea beetle eggs are very small and cannot be detected. It is best to sow turnip seeds directly under cover.
Celery root protected by insect netting
The celery fly (Philophylla heraclei) is 5 to 6 mm long and the female lays about 150 eggs in small groups on the leaves. The larvae develop in 25 to 30 days. They form excavations that form white spots called mines. The excrement shines through between the two epidermis of the leaf. In the event of a major attack, the larvae dig galleries in the petioles. The first generation of flying adults appears in May and the second in June-July. The nets can be removed around 15 August, but this exposes the celery to carrot flies.
The carrot fly maggot (Psilia rosae) is a serious pest of vegetable crops. The adult is 4 to 5 mm long. The eggs are invisible, isolated or clustered in the soil. The larvae dig galleries in the roots, making them unfit for storage. This pest is polyphagous and can migrate to other vegetables such as parsnips, celery and sometimes parsley. The pulp overwinters in the soil near the cultivated plots it has invaded. The first generation emerges in spring in a staggered manner until July. A second generation emerges from September. There may even be a third generation in autumn. In the Provence-Alpes-Côte d’Azur region, carrot foliage can be attacked by various moths, including the very polyphagous Spodoptera littoralis (Spodoptera exigua).
In winter, carrots keep very well in the field if they are protected from frosts by a cover of straw or lawn mowing. In the Provence-Alpes-Côte region, I have sometimes seen carrot flies emerge in the middle of winter on sunny, warmer days. In the weeks that follow, the roots are invaded by larvae. For this reason, insect netting should not be removed in the autumn and winter until the carrot harvest is complete.
Note that adults of Spodoptera littoralis feed on pollen and nectar and can be found in hedges, especially when they are provided with floral species (such as the oleander, which is very common in the Provence-Alpes-Côte d’Azur region). Abandon all the medieval infusions proposed here and there based on nettles, wormwood, tansy, fern... whose effectiveness is null. Only anti-insect nets will ensure an effective protection during the whole growing period.
A few adult moths may appear under the anti-insect nets, for example from pupae accidentally introduced during compost spreading or from a previous unprotected crop, from egg-laying on the nets and introduction of the larvae through an accidental opening... As the caterpillars are not always visible through the nets, predation is most noticeable when the flying adult tries to get out of the protection. The crop should then be inspected. If defoliating caterpillars are present, an attempt can be made to destroy them by spraying with esterified rapeseed oil, unless you have introduced ladybirds for aphid control (see below: important recommendations). When the carrot plantation is not very large, which is often the case in home gardens, the moth larvae, which are often few in number under the insect netting, can be destroyed by hand.
Leeks and onions are often attacked by the larva of a butterfly, the acrolepiopsis assectella (Acrolepia assectella), or other moths such as the ipsilon (Agrotis ipsilon aneituma) and the harvest moth (Agrotis segetum), which can also be found on sugar beet, potatoes and cereals.
All alliums are threatened by the acrolepiopsis, also known as the leek moth, which can be confused with two other leek bio-agressors: the leaf miner and the onion fly. As far as the leek moth is concerned, the adult moth appears in April-May. The females lay eggs on the leaves of the host plant and then burrow into the stem to form galleries. The caterpillars in turn become adults that will lay new eggs between June and mid-August. Depending on the weather conditions, a third generation can occur between the end of August and the end of September. The leafminer has caused particularly serious damage since its arrival in France.
The onion fly (elia antiqua) is a diptera measuring 5 to 6 mm in length which has the particularity of producing maggots that like the base of roots and leaves. Bacteria settle in the galleries, causing tissue rot. Up to 5 generations can be observed during a growing season.
Alliums are sometimes attacked as early as April - May by the "onion criocene", a beetle that is very recognisable by its red colour. From June, the larvae devour the leaves.
In the Provence-Alpes-Côte d’Azur region, as in the entire Mediterranean region, the brachicera weevil, which affects garlic, but can also attack other bulbs, is rife from May onwards.
In the absence of protective netting, it is very difficult to protect alliums against all these bioaggressors. To avoid the use of pesticides, some amateur gardeners use diluted bleach, which is just as toxic for the soil's biodiversity as chlorinated pesticides, which have been banned in France.
Radishes are very often attacked by the maggot of a fly (Phorbia floralis) which digs galleries in the roots. Within 15 days, the radishes become unpalatable. For this reason, the cultivation of radishes is often abandoned by amateur gardeners who do not wish to protect their crops with an insecticide. They are not wrong for two reasons:
Radishes have a short crop cycle and a curative treatment with an insecticide is always problematic. The choice of insecticide, the timing and the way it is applied is a matter for a professional.
The use of synthetic or organic insecticides has become obsolete, as it is very easy to protect radish crops with insect netting. It is probably one of the plants that is best protected with insect netting. With this type of protection, you will find that radish cultivation has become an easy crop without any losses, regardless of the variety. As with all other vegetables protected by insect netting, the absence of pests inside the protection does not prevent crop rotation.
Root vegetables are not the only plants that can be protected by insect netting. All vegetables that do not need to be pollinated can be protected by insect netting. This is the case for all varieties of lettuce. These are often attacked by caterpillars of moths (defoliator moths), especially the Autographa gamma caterpillar, which is a moth; its light green caterpillar devours the salad leaves.
Salads are frequently victims of several species of aphids such as Nasonovia ribisnigri, commonly known as the lettuce aphid. These aphids can easily pass through insect netting when the mesh size is 1 mm. Some aphid predators should be introduced to neutralise these attacks (see article: Importing beneficial insects against aphids).
Other aphids attack salad roots (lettuce aphids lanigères). The damage is not very visible and is characterised by a reduction in the growth of the plant. Root damage is most noticeable when the lettuce is pulled up with its roots. Many yellowish-white insects are found along the roots. These insects have a conspicuous tuft that looks like a woolly coat. This aphid is also able to transmit the lettuce mosaic virus.
Crops with a flowering period
The protection of bean and pea crops with insect netting can only be carried out outside the flowering period unless pollinators are introduced into the shelter. As soon as the first flowers appear, the nets should be removed to allow the pollinating insects to act. During this period, it is impossible to avoid the installation of aphids.
With the new regulations on the use of pesticides by private individuals, there are few chemical substances available to reduce aphid pressure, even in organic farming. Pyrethrin-based preparations require very frequent re-spraying with the risk of being invaded by aphids resistant to this organic pesticide. Synthetic pyrethroids with a longer duration of action are more effective, but they are now banned and can also induce resistance. In the nomenclature of biocontrol plant protection products, preparations containing rapeseed oil are an interesting alternative to deal with this recurrent problem in the bean crop (see article: biocontrol plant protection products). Rapeseed oil should be used in early spring when ladybirds are not yet active. Outside this period, importing ladybird larvae is often very effective.
Importing adult hoverflies into the shelters avoids the need to remove insect protection. Adult hoverflies feed on pollen and nectar and are therefore valuable pollinators. Hoverflies like certain plants such as fennel, which can be cultivated for this purpose, or weed flowers such as Queen Anne's lace, oxalis, field mustard.... A butterfly net with an adjustable telescopic handle makes it easy to catch adult hoverflies.
Important recommendations:
Root bio-agressors are everywhere. Therefore, all the edges of the nets should be buried or wooden or iron obstacles with some soil should be placed on top of the nets to block all the passages that can be used by the adult insects.
With tunnels fitted with anti-insect nets, we find ourselves with the same problems as with greenhouse crops, in particular a significant risk of development of certain bio-aggressors which, for various reasons, manage to get inside the protection. This is particularly the case for aphids. However, these can be easily controlled by beneficial insects.
It is often impossible to avoid an invasion of aphids inside the protections when the mesh size is not regular. Other pests can also settle under insect netting which can be controlled by specific predators used by greenhouse growers. More than 60 species of beneficial insects are now available for integrated biological protection for sale on websites such as here or here.
Here are some examples:
•
Against whiteflies : The polyphagous Swirski-Mite (Amblyseius swirski). It also feeds on thrips and weaver mites.
•
Against weaver mites and leafminer larvae: the mite Neoseiulus californicus (also known as Amblyseius californicus), which is naturally present in the Mediterranean region, the Mirical bug (Macrolophus pygmaeus) or certain paratisoids such as Eretmocerus eremicus and Encarsia formosa.
•
Against mealy bugs: the paratisoid heminopteran Microterys flavus.
•
Against Thrips: Mites of the swirksi-mite family (Amblyseius cucumeris, Amblyseius degenerans) or certain predatory bugs belonging to the Orius family known to be very voracious.
These useful auxiliaries are often sold in large quantities for greenhouse growers and must be renewed frequently.
Beware of solutions proposed on certain websites and books on gardening that have never been the subject of serious scientific studies, such as marigolds to keep aphids and other insects away. I have never found that introducing carnations under insect netting reduces the aphid population. On the contrary, the aphids continue to develop quietly as long as ladybirds are not introduced into the shelter. The fact that the carnation does not easily pick up aphids does not mean that it protects other plants by emitting odorous substances.
Aphids are vectors of viral diseases and control of this pest is detailed in another article on this website at this location. Often the leaves of plants protected by insect netting end up touching the netting, which attracts certain biting pests that lay eggs on the netting. Aphid larvae, being smaller than adults, can easily get inside the protection by passing through the mesh. Protected from their own predators, these aphids will proliferate at an infernal rate. A crop can be lost in a few weeks if you don't intervene quickly to reduce their proliferation. Adult winged aphids will move to the top of the netting to try to get out of the protection, warning the gardener that he is already facing a major invasion. To avoid this problem, a forecasting model must be adhered to which includes at least the following actions:
•
Check the base of the collars, the stems and the back of the leaves from time to time. If aphid larvae are already present, import ladybirds immediately. Never forget that ladybirds are the most effective ally of the gardener in dealing with this problem, especially as they are easily available on the internet. As a general rule, as soon as a vegetable plant touches an insect net, you should import at least 2 to 4 ladybirds per m² as a preventive measure.
•
Add flower-producing plants to the shelter to feed the ladybirds when the aphid colony disappears.
•
It is important to check whether predators of beneficial axillaries have entered the shelter, such as spiders or ants. The absence of ladybird reproduction introduced into a shelter where aphids are thriving is often a sign of the presence of ladybird predators. The presence of a web in a shelter necessarily indicates the presence of a spider, which is sure to feed on beneficial insects. Ant nests should be systematically searched for and destroyed with pyrethrins. This treatment should be carried out after the beneficial organisms have been temporarily discarded.
•
Small wooden (or metal) bars coated with glue can also be placed around an insect guard. This barrier must be carefully constructed, as the smallest unprotected passage will allow ants to deposit their pheromone trail leading to galleries dug under the nets or small holes left by the gardener, allowing the entire colony to invade the insect guard. The glue has the advantage of not being washed away by rain or watering equipment.
Colony of flying aphids inside an insect tunnel
If there is a heavy invasion of aphids inside the tunnels, the nets should not be removed until the invasion is under control. Otherwise, the aphid population is so high that it could cause an ecological disaster in your garden and among your neighbours. Beware, aphids can travel great distances (1) and some have become resistant to pesticides (including the neonicotinoids now banned in France). An aphid invasion is easily controlled by introducing beneficial insects into the tunnels, even if the invasion is large.
A colony of ladybirds inside an insect net housing a carrot crop
It will just take longer to get rid of the aphids. You will find that by introducing ladybirds into an insect tunnel, the dreaded green peach aphid, which is known to be resistant to pesticides, is no longer a problem. Other useful aphid-eating insects such as midges, hemerobes and lacewing larvae can also be introduced if you can find them. Ladybirds can be ordered from some garden centres. There are also websites where you can get ladybirds, such as the naturen website (two-spotted ladybirds or Adalia bipunctata).
Or click here to obtain ladybird eggs or larvae.
Turnip crop in insect-proof tunnel invaded by aphids
The seven-spotted ladybird (Coccinnelles septempunctata), which is now being reared by specialised societies, is known to be very voracious and polyphagous, and preys on aphids on low-growing cultivated and non-cultivated plants.
The import of ladybird eggs or larvae is more interesting when it comes to protecting vegetable plants in the field, as these larvae cannot fly away to other horizons if they do not like their new habitat. After a period of adaptation, the larvae always end up taking possession of the premises.
Ladybirds are very sensitive to chemicals; conventional or even organic pesticides should not be used before or after the introduction of ladybirds into the protection tunnels.
Ladybirds introduced into the insect shelter cannot escape to the outside when the aphid population is scarce. When there are no more aphids in the shelter, being particularly voracious, ladybirds end up devouring other pests present in the shelter such as tobacco whitefly. The ladybird is therefore a very useful tool for controlling all the pests that can enter the shelter. It is less obvious when the ladybird has the possibility to travel to find its favourite food.
hoverfly
Another possibility is the introduction of the girdled hoverfly (Episyrphus balteatus), which occurs in large numbers in the wild on wild flowers or on plants cultivated by man, the adult feeding on the pollen of the flowers. This Diptera was introduced in 1999 to control aphids in greenhouse pepper cultivation. At 20°, depending on the aphid population, a female hoverfly lays between 500 and 1000 eggs near aphid colonies. The mortality rate among the eggs is high, but the larvae are very voracious. Hoverfly larvae have a passive behaviour towards their prey; if their food disappears, they stop looking for it and wait for their prey to come back. This is not the case with ladybird larvae, which move around in search of their prey. For this reason hoverfly larvae contribute less than ladybirds to the control of an aphid infestation.
Adult daylilies feed on aphids. Lacewing larvae are predators of aphids. Lacewings are active during the period from May to September, with 2 or 3 generations in succession. You can buy lacewing larvae by clicking here.
By reading this, the reader will have quickly realised that an insect net can also be used as a shelter for raising ladybirds, but there are several difficulties to be taken into account:
•
The ladybird is very voracious and its introduction will eventually destroy the aphid colonies completely. It is then necessary to introduce other aphid-covered plants grown for this purpose (e.g. in pots). Otherwise the ladybirds will starve. The ladybirds can also be moved to another area where there are aphids. Avoid introducing Asian ladybirds into a pest control area where native ladybirds have already been introduced, as their larvae will be eaten by Asian ladybirds even if aphids are present.
•
The ladybirds will reproduce in the shelter as long as they find plenty of food. If not, the larvae become cannibals. In the end, if you do not have a crop of aphids to feed your ladybirds from time to time, their population will be reduced. The covers should be opened so that the ladybirds can find their food elsewhere. It is wise to keep some ladybirds in an insect shelter. It is also necessary to release the ladybirds in autumn as soon as the first cold weather appears so that they can seek shelter for the winter.
•
When the aphids have disappeared inside the covers, flowering plants can also be introduced. The ladybirds will feed on the nectar, but their reproduction will be stopped.
•
Aphids attract ants, which feed on their honeydew. The ants eventually nest in the protection which is a major problem. The ants protect the aphids from the ladybirds and may even eat their larvae. The ladybird population then does not increase. If there is a massive invasion of ants, the ladybird farm should be moved to another shelter. The ants can also be eliminated by treating their nests with nematodes, which can be purchased here and here. In order to avoid this frequent problem, it is essential to treat ant nests throughout the cultivated area and especially near the shelters.
•
Ants are not the only predators that can get into the shelters by using tiny holes or by digging galleries. A snail or a locust will certainly feed on vegetable plants and reproduce with substantial losses. These pests are most often introduced by accident when the nets are opened, for example when weeding or thinning out the semi.
Growing under a tunnel with insect netting with an assortment of turnips, radishes, lettuce and beetroot is a good solution for breeding ladybirds.
For winter storage of ladybirds, click here.
1) Les pucerons -insectes N° 141 – INRA – Alain Fraval